Serial season 3, episode 5 & The Dream

Serial season 3, episode 5 & The Dream

In Serial episode 5, Pleas Baby Pleas, Sarah brings us inside the prosecutor’s office, giving us a view of what it’s like to be one of too-few prosecutors in a system with too many felonies to prosecute, with some decisions made for justice and some for expediency. But does this episode live up to Serial's promise? The panel is split 3-1.

Then, we review The Dream, a new podcast from Stitcher that looks at the unsavory world of multi-level marketing companies, and the reasons some people get sucked in.

For our review without spoilers, skip to: 1:06:41.

In Crime of the Week: Apple, peaches, pumpkin pie. Who's not ready, holler "I."


  • Bombas - go to and use the code CRIME for 20% off your first order

  • Talkspace - go to, and use the code CRIMEWRITERS to get $45 off your first month 

  • Legacybox - go to for 40% off your first order

  • Daily Harvest - go to and enter promo code CRIME to get three cups free in your first box

  • Evelyn & Bobbie - go to and use code CRIME to get a free pair of underwear with any purchase

  • Under My Skin by Lisa Unger - new from Park Row Books